CA108 Psychophysical Harmony, Physicalism, & God w/ Brian Cutter

Counter Apologetics

内容由Emerson Green提供。所有播客内容（包括剧集、图形和播客描述）均由 Emerson Green 或其播客平台合作伙伴直接上传和提供。如果您认为有人在未经您许可的情况下使用您的受版权保护的作品，您可以按照此处概述的流程进行操作https://zh.player.fm/legal。

1+ y ago 1:05:16

MP3•单集首页

Dr. Brian Cutter joins me to discuss his paper, ‘Psychophysical Harmony: A New Argument for Theism‘, coauthored with Dr. Dustin Crummett.

After talking about epiphenomenalism and why William James’ argument against it works against all views in philosophy of mind (with the lone exception of Type-A materialism), we explain why psychophysical harmony seems so improbable. We also discuss what I consider to be one of the weirder features of physicalism – the metaphysical impossibility of inverts, zombies, disharmony, and so on – and why one’s views about metaphysical modality won’t help you escape the argument from psychophysical harmony. In addition to touching on a few objections, we also talk about the underdetermination of the data, and why psychophysical harmony may be equally good evidence for some hypotheses of those who exist in The Nagel Zone.

Subscribe on YouTube

Consider supporting the show on Patreon here or Walden Pod here

Listen to our sister show, Walden Pod here

Music by ichika Nito & Whalers. Used with permission.

Follow me on Twitter @waldenpod

linktr.ee/emersongreen

169集单集