Artwork

内容由Atheist Community of Austin提供。所有播客内容(包括剧集、图形和播客描述)均由 Atheist Community of Austin 或其播客平台合作伙伴直接上传和提供。如果您认为有人在未经您许可的情况下使用您的受版权保护的作品,您可以按照此处概述的流程进行操作https://zh.player.fm/legal
Player FM -播客应用
使用Player FM应用程序离线!

Understanding Belief Formation

19:22
 
分享
 

Manage episode 455360954 series 2246476
内容由Atheist Community of Austin提供。所有播客内容(包括剧集、图形和播客描述)均由 Atheist Community of Austin 或其播客平台合作伙伴直接上传和提供。如果您认为有人在未经您许可的情况下使用您的受版权保护的作品,您可以按照此处概述的流程进行操作https://zh.player.fm/legal
What delusions can tell us about the cognitive nature of belief

The Conversation, By Michael Connors and Peter W Halligan, on November 19, 2024
http://theconversation.com/what-delusions-can-tell-us-about-the-cognitive-nature-of-belief-243627


This episode of The Non-Prophets explores the intricate relationship between belief, delusion, and religious convictions. Hosted by Eli Slack, the discussion is prompted by an article from The Conversation by Michael Connors and Peter Hallagan, examining whether beliefs and delusions share common psychological roots. The article highlights that the primary difference between the two lies not in the mental process of formation but in the number of adherents, challenging our perceptions of "normal" beliefs versus delusional thinking.
The panel delves into a case study of a woman experiencing postpartum psychosis, whose delusions were shaped by interpreting ordinary stimuli in the context of her personal biases. This underscores a universal mechanism: beliefs, whether true or false, arise from subjective interpretations of sensory input filtered through emotional and cognitive biases. Eli emphasizes that religious beliefs, while not inherently indicative of mental instability, share no epistemological advantage over delusions.
The group critiques the article's lack of a clear definition of belief, a flaw that hampers meaningful discourse. Kelley asserts that beliefs are often embraced without critical thought, making them stagnant compared to an active pursuit of understanding. The panel also discusses societal double standards—other religions are dismissed as myths, while Christianity often escapes such scrutiny due to its dominant cultural presence.
Aaron and Kelley explore how psychology struggles to distinguish beliefs from delusions, suggesting that the objective truth—or lack thereof—defines the difference. Aaron provocatively argues that religion meets the criteria for delusion, as it lacks verifiable evidence, yet garners social acceptance when widely shared. Kelley supports this by highlighting how belief systems solidify when critical thought ceases.
The conversation concludes with reflections on societal norms and the dangers of uncritically accepted beliefs. While respecting individual faiths, the panel underscores the value of skepticism and evidence-based reasoning in navigating the complexities of belief and delusion.
The Non-Prophets, Episode 23.49.3 featuring Jimmy Jr., Kelley Laughlin, Aaron Jensen and Eli Slack

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-non-prophets--3254964/support.
  continue reading

795集单集

Artwork

Understanding Belief Formation

The Non-Prophets

1,544 subscribers

published

icon分享
 
Manage episode 455360954 series 2246476
内容由Atheist Community of Austin提供。所有播客内容(包括剧集、图形和播客描述)均由 Atheist Community of Austin 或其播客平台合作伙伴直接上传和提供。如果您认为有人在未经您许可的情况下使用您的受版权保护的作品,您可以按照此处概述的流程进行操作https://zh.player.fm/legal
What delusions can tell us about the cognitive nature of belief

The Conversation, By Michael Connors and Peter W Halligan, on November 19, 2024
http://theconversation.com/what-delusions-can-tell-us-about-the-cognitive-nature-of-belief-243627


This episode of The Non-Prophets explores the intricate relationship between belief, delusion, and religious convictions. Hosted by Eli Slack, the discussion is prompted by an article from The Conversation by Michael Connors and Peter Hallagan, examining whether beliefs and delusions share common psychological roots. The article highlights that the primary difference between the two lies not in the mental process of formation but in the number of adherents, challenging our perceptions of "normal" beliefs versus delusional thinking.
The panel delves into a case study of a woman experiencing postpartum psychosis, whose delusions were shaped by interpreting ordinary stimuli in the context of her personal biases. This underscores a universal mechanism: beliefs, whether true or false, arise from subjective interpretations of sensory input filtered through emotional and cognitive biases. Eli emphasizes that religious beliefs, while not inherently indicative of mental instability, share no epistemological advantage over delusions.
The group critiques the article's lack of a clear definition of belief, a flaw that hampers meaningful discourse. Kelley asserts that beliefs are often embraced without critical thought, making them stagnant compared to an active pursuit of understanding. The panel also discusses societal double standards—other religions are dismissed as myths, while Christianity often escapes such scrutiny due to its dominant cultural presence.
Aaron and Kelley explore how psychology struggles to distinguish beliefs from delusions, suggesting that the objective truth—or lack thereof—defines the difference. Aaron provocatively argues that religion meets the criteria for delusion, as it lacks verifiable evidence, yet garners social acceptance when widely shared. Kelley supports this by highlighting how belief systems solidify when critical thought ceases.
The conversation concludes with reflections on societal norms and the dangers of uncritically accepted beliefs. While respecting individual faiths, the panel underscores the value of skepticism and evidence-based reasoning in navigating the complexities of belief and delusion.
The Non-Prophets, Episode 23.49.3 featuring Jimmy Jr., Kelley Laughlin, Aaron Jensen and Eli Slack

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-non-prophets--3254964/support.
  continue reading

795集单集

Todos los episodios

×
 
Loading …

欢迎使用Player FM

Player FM正在网上搜索高质量的播客,以便您现在享受。它是最好的播客应用程序,适用于安卓、iPhone和网络。注册以跨设备同步订阅。

 

快速参考指南

边探索边听这个节目
播放