Episode #20: Old Giants vs. New Titans: SpaceX, Legacy Contractors, and the Cost of Progress

Stewart Squared

Welcome to Stewart Squared podcast with the two Stewart Alsops! In this special episode, recorded on a scenic drive up the 101 from Los Angeles to Santa Barbara, the conversation explores a broad range of topics, from the evolution of Apple's iPhone as a "super tool" due to its unique hardware-software integration to Google's challenges in fostering innovation despite its moonshot projects. The Stewarts also touch on the growing influence of SpaceX in the aerospace industry, shifting paradigms in defense contracting, and the nuanced dynamics of AI development, with nods to ChatGPT, perplexity search, and the competitive landscape of large language models. Alongside tech and industry insights, they reflect on family history, storytelling, and the enduring legacy of innovation in journalism.

Check out this GPT we trained on the conversation!

Timestamps

00:00 Introduction and Road Trip Setup

00:09 Apple's Hardware and Software Integration

02:41 Google's Approach and Challenges

03:29 Comparing Apple and Samsung

04:13 Steve Jobs' Philosophy and Legacy

05:40 Google's Moonshots and Company Culture

07:12 The Role of Venture Capital in Innovation

07:41 Apple's Research and Development

19:52 Evaluating AI and Intelligence

24:03 The Evolution of Publishing

29:41 Industry Insights and Analyst Role

30:11 Fortune Magazine and Controversial Opinions

32:23 Intel's Video Conferencing Failure

35:33 Government Contracts and SpaceX Disruption

39:53 The Evolution of Publishing

45:45 Family Stories and Historical Anecdotes

49:28 Great Uncle Joe's War Stories

52:58 Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Key Insights

1. Apple’s Strength in Vertical Integration: A key discussion point was Apple’s decision to tightly integrate hardware and software, which has enabled the iPhone to excel as a "super tool." This strategy, rooted in Steve Jobs' vision, allows Apple to eliminate compatibility issues and enhance user experience. In contrast, Google's more fragmented approach with Android has faced challenges due to the varied hardware used by manufacturers, such as Samsung.
2. Google’s Innovation Struggles and Moonshots: Despite Google’s enormous resources and 98% profit margins in search, the company has faced criticism for its lack of follow-through on innovative projects. The episode highlighted Google’s early lead in AI with the creation of the Transformer model, yet OpenAI capitalized on it more effectively. This discussion raised questions about how large organizations balance research, productization, and internal complacency.
3. The Competitive Edge of SpaceX in Aerospace: SpaceX was presented as a disruptive force in the aerospace industry, outperforming legacy players like Northrop Grumman, Lockheed Martin, and Raytheon by pioneering reusable rocket technology. The conversation emphasized how traditional defense contractors relied on outdated cost-plus contracts, which rewarded inefficiency, whereas SpaceX’s innovation-driven model has drastically reduced launch costs.
4. The Evolution of Consumer Habits in Technology: The hosts explored how habits shape consumer loyalty, such as the difficulty of switching from Google Search to alternatives like Perplexity. They discussed the intentional design choices that reinforce brand loyalty, underscoring the challenge of breaking ingrained user behaviors without offering a significantly superior product or experience.
5. AI’s Role in Shaping Future Products and Research: There was a thought-provoking discussion about the evolving capabilities of large language models and the difficulty of evaluating "smarter" AI. The hosts debated the nuances of intelligence, arguing that while AI can demonstrate impressive reasoning, it lacks the real-time processing that defines human cognition, particularly in high-stakes, real-world environments.
6. The Shifting Landscape of Media and Publishing: The conversation touched on the transformation of journalism, from the manual processes of desktop publishing in the 1980s to the streamlined tools available today, such as Substack. They reflected on how this evolution has empowered individual creators while simultaneously eliminating the barriers to entry, changing the role of traditional editors and gatekeepers.
7. Historical Reflections on Legacy and Innovation: The episode concluded with personal anecdotes about family history, particularly the legacy of the Alsop family in journalism and public service. These stories illustrated the enduring importance of communication, innovation, and the ability to distill complex ideas for a general audience, drawing parallels between past and present challenges in conveying critical insights to the public.