250. The Prophetic Challenge of Deconstruction, with Scot McKnight, author of Invisible Jesus

Spiritual Life and Leadership

Send me a text! I’d love to know what you're thinking!

In this episode, we’re taking a deep-dive into the complex and, at times, nerve-wracking experience of deconstruction. Leaders often worry about its impact on their roles, their authority, and on the harmony or unity of their church communities. But what if deconstruction is less about tearing down faith and more about stripping away what's non-essential, centering instead on Jesus?

In this epidsode, Scot McKnight, author of Invisible Jesus, sheds light on how deconstruction can be a path to a more Christ-focused faith, emphasizing the importance of creating supportive spaces for exploring and asking questions. This conversation is crucial for ministry leaders navigating their own or their congregants' journeys of faith reformation.
THIS EPISODE'S HIGHLIGHTS INCLUDE:

• Markus Watson addresses the nervousness leaders feel about deconstruction and its potential impacts on their beliefs.
• Scot McKnight highlights that leaders fear deconstruction because it threatens their job security, authority, and influence.
• People undergoing deconstruction can disrupt church communities, creating anxiety about church teachings.
• Markus Watson emphasizes the need for leaders to find safe spaces outside their church community for discussing deconstruction.
• Scot McKnight suggests that churches should support and provide safe exploration spaces instead of trying to control questioning individuals.
• Pastors face pressure to have all the answers, and questioning can trigger their insecurities about their role and authority.
• Markus Watson discusses how churches need to shift their culture to become open to questioning and changes.
• Scot McKnight reflects on his book "Invisible Jesus," addressing how deconstruction is not about abandoning faith but refocusing on Christ by removing non-essential elements.
• A study cited by Scot McKnight shows that 86% of people who undergo deconstruction remain in the church, although they may change congregations.
• Deconstruction resembles a personal Protestant Reformation where individuals reassess and personalize their faith journey.
• Scot McKnight draws parallels between deconstruction and historical movements aimed at shedding unnecessary church practices or beliefs, focusing on continual reform.
• Scot McKnight states that Jesus acted as a deconstructor, challenging the law within Judaism similar to the prophets.
• The church's role should involve listening to deconstructors rather than fearing or dismissing them, promoting an adaptive leadership approach.

RELEVANT RESOURCES AND LINKS:

• Scot McKnight:
  • Substack
• Books mentioned:
  • Invisible Jesus, by Scot McKnight and Tommy Phillips
  • A Church Called Tov, by Scot McKnight and Laura Barringer
  • Revelation for the Rest of Us, by Scot McKnight and Cody Matchett
• Related episodes:
  • 171. Leading Your Ministry as a Dissident Disciple, with Scot McKnight
  • 98. Deconstruction and Reconstruction, with A.J. Swoboda
  • 92. Against a Culture of Abuse, with Scot McKnight and Laura Barringer

Click HERE to get my FREE online course, BECOMING LEADERS OF SHALOM.